The Minority in Parliament says Foreign Affairs Ministry records do not support GH¢16.4 million of the GH¢49.7 million spent evacuating Ghanaians from South Africa, and wants an independent audit.
The figure comes from Nana Asafo-Adjei Ayeh, the Member of Parliament for Bosome-Freho and Deputy Ranking Member of Parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee. He based it on a review of a report of more than 200 pages that the ministry supplied in response to his Right to Information request.
The Minority does not allege that money was stolen. Its case is that the ministry’s payment registers and flight records, as supplied, cannot be reconciled with the official count of 1,964 evacuees, and that the gap needs explaining.
The stakes go beyond one operation. The evacuation was unbudgeted, and the ministry has already asked the Auditor-General to examine every evacuation it has run since 2017. The Minority says an audit by a private firm would carry more weight.
How the money was spent
Foreign Affairs Minister Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa announced the total of GH¢49,721,786 on 7 September, after an operation that ran from 27 May to 4 September and followed xenophobic attacks on foreign nationals in South Africa. The government paid GH¢33,721,786 and Engineers and Planners, a company owned by businessman Ibrahim Mahama, contributed GH¢16 million.
According to the ministry’s report, chartered flights cost GH¢27,183,700 and commercial tickets and layovers GH¢9,420,463.68. A further GH¢10.802 million covered a GH¢5,000 reintegration grant and a GH¢500 transport allowance for each of the 1,964 returnees.
What the Minority says it found
Ayeh said only 824 names appeared in the signed registers for both the reintegration grant and the transport allowance. Set against the official 1,964, that leaves 1,140 people whose combined GH¢5,500 payments, worth GH¢6.27 million, the Minority says the registers do not establish.
On flights, the Minority counted 926 passengers on chartered flights, which would leave 1,038 on commercial flights. It says the records it received evidence only 247 commercial passengers. Using an average ticket cost of about GH¢9,076, it values the travel of the remaining 791 people at about GH¢7.18 million.
Together, those two gaps come to GH¢13,449,116, about 27 percent of the total.
Duplicates and minors
The Minority also cited duplicate names in the reintegration register, the transport register and at least one flight manifest, along with blank and unsigned entries. Duplicate entries do not on their own show that anyone was paid twice, and the Minority is asking the ministry to establish whether they affected payments or the headcount.
It separately counted 442 minors among the 1,708 people listed in the reintegration register and asked how payments meant for children were made and recorded. If each child received the full package, that would come to GH¢2.431 million. Payments to minors are not in themselves improper, and the Minority has not said they were.
Adding its estimates for minors and duplicates, the Minority puts the total requiring explanation at GH¢16,423,470, about 33 percent of the bill.
The statement leaves some questions about its own method. It does not say whether any of the 442 minors are also among the 1,140 unmatched evacuees, which would mean some amounts are counted twice. Its closing demand also cites a different total, GH¢16,302,586, a difference of GH¢120,884 that it does not explain.
The ministry’s position
The ministry had not publicly responded to the latest findings by the time of publication. Ablakwa said when he announced the cost that the bill had been paid in full with no outstanding liabilities, and that the evacuation had not been budgeted for because it could not have been anticipated.
The Minority first demanded supporting records at a press conference on 10 September. “If the books are closed, then let’s open the books,” Ayeh said then. The caucus later boycotted a closed-door committee briefing by the minister. The committee’s chairman, Dr Alfred Okoe Vanderpuije, said at the time that Ablakwa was committed to giving the Minority whatever information it needed.
The Minority wants the audit carried out by Deloitte, KPMG, PricewaterhouseCoopers or Ernst & Young, or a firm of similar standing independent of the ministry and its contractors, with the results published. The ministry asked the Auditor-General on 17 September to conduct a special audit of all its evacuation exercises since 2017.

